| 1) | #8 | Anderson IN | (0,10) | -0.735 | -1.735 |
| 2) | #7 | Manchester | (1,9) | -0.902 | -1.702 |
| 3) | #2 | Rose-Hulman | (7,3) | -0.912 | -0.512 |
| 4) | #4 | Franklin | (4,6) | -0.915 | -1.115 |
| 5) | #1 | Mt St Joseph | (9,2) | -0.938 | -0.302 |
| 6) | #5 | Defiance | (4,6) | -0.992 | -1.192 |
| 7) | #3 | Hanover | (7,3) | -1.040 | -0.640 |
| 8) | #6 | Bluffton | (4,6) | -1.078 | -1.278 |